Repository navigation
Group @ menu: handle/.home and (Friend) inserts do not call room members #1141
Description
Owner decision (2026-10-25 Asia/Shanghai)
拉了群就应该都能发消息，而不是还要加好友 — co-members in a live shared group must be able to message each other (group @ and sidebar 1:1) without a separate friendship / Sharing grant.
Repro A — @ insert / no answer (研发组)
- Ordinary group with friend's Chief + local Architect/Backend/…
@picker: Architect asarchitect.…home, others as(Friend).- Lines that call nobody:
@@architect.flybot….home …,Backend (Friend) 你好啊(no@).
Repro B — sidebar DM not friends
- From the shared-group context, open sidebar chat Architect (flybot682b8a43) (projected / cross-home seat).
- Send 「你是谁」.
- Actual:
Not sent: you are not friends with this Bot. Add them from + Add friend. - Expected: send succeeds because both sides share a live group (same spirit as Name the room on a platform-room send: pass room_id on the claimed-room path only #881 face-room / Friend Bot in shared local group cannot message peer @…home — blocked as not shared #1126 ticket @; Deliver shared-room mentions without a Sharing grant #1130 merged for ticket mentions — this is the DM/sidebar path).
Acceptance
- Group
@insert uses seat/Bot name the host routes on; no@@; no.homeas the call token; no(Friend)-only insert. - Live co-members: sidebar/DM send and in-group @ work without friendship.
- After leaving the room (or never sharing one): stranger refuse may remain.
- Tests for insert routing + room-scoped reach without friendship.
Claim and fix.
Activity
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Claimed by bot-im. CloudAgent bc-7b72d208 fixing. Owner asked to fix after 研发组 repro:
@@architect.…homeandBackend (Friend)call nobody.Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Owner: 拉了群就应该都能发消息，而不是还要加好友. Sidebar DM to Architect (flybot682b8a43) hits Not sent: you are not friends — expand fix beyond @ insert (#1130 already merged for ticket @).
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Same rule, another path (FlyBot 交付组): after @chief, reply fails with
Chief is not friends with @flybot98b8ecba.home: that friendship is with @architect.flybot682b8a43.home only.Owner: friendship via Architect must not block other co-members in a shared group from messaging that friend home.
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Owner: flybot98b8ecba already deleted, but sends still show rejected / not-friends. Stale remote seat + friendship-via-Architect-only must clear when the friend home is gone; shared-group co-members must not depend on that friendship edge.
Let co-members message a shared room without a friendship (ThinkFlowL…
Sanitize the group @ call name taken from a handle (ThinkFlowLab#1151)
Accept a result or send it back from the Inbox Done list (ThinkFlowLa…