From f964ae8a72797827f5ebfd804fce1f2f400325b0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kjgbot Date: Tue, 1 Sep 2026 12:18:35 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?docs(state):=20gate=202=20evidence=20citation?= =?UTF-8?q?=20=E2=80=94=20iter=205=20(all-runs=20survey=20+=20narrowed=20s?= =?UTF-8?q?cope)?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit iter 4 (779268e) went M:pass H:fail S:pass. Only remaining H blocker: the rule table claimed "8 subscription.matched" and "every run ended in a declared completionReason" but the transcript literally captured only ONE run's journal. Also an H concern flagged calling this the "durable-execution plane" when the run demonstrates sustained execution, not crash / restart durability. iter 5: - Added an all-runs terminal-entry survey section. One literal shell loop reads seq 4 (subscription.matched) and seq 7 (run.completed) from every /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/runs/*.sqlite3, with the literal loop pasted and its literal output (18 lines, one per entry across the 9 runs) inlined. The rule table now cites this survey directly for the "9 subscription.matched" and "9 of 9 runs ended in typed completionReason" claims. - "Proof of" line narrowed from "the trigger + durable-execution plane runs" to "the trigger + step-dispatch plane runs, unattended and sustained ... This is *sustained execution* under real events; it is not *crash / restart durability* — that is a separate property this run did not exercise." Same narrowing echoed in the new "Unattended + scheduled (sustained)" row of the rule table. - Fresh consistent snapshot at 2026-09-01T10:16:24Z (was 10:11:27Z). 9 runs (was 8), 9 dedupe entries, kernel/poller uptime 01:38:45 / 01:38:16 — all recaptured in one shell burst so `date`, `sqlite3`, `ps -o etime`, and the all-runs survey are consistent by construction. - Appendix ULID list updated to 9 entries. - STATE.md header timestamp bumped to 10:16 UTC. - STATE.md still contains no drift-prone counts — the iter 4 change to remove specific numbers from the block is preserved and this iter demonstrates why (counts moved 8 → 9 in five minutes; the block did not need to change). Gate 2 remains AMBER. The two outstanding done-when clauses (trigger- plane liveness sweep + agent-runtime execution) are itemized in both the STATE block and the evidence file's rule table. AMBER→GREEN remains Khaliq's read on the enclosed evidence. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 --- ops/STATE.md | 76 +++--- ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md | 243 ++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 288 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-) create mode 100644 ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md diff --git a/ops/STATE.md b/ops/STATE.md index 9a921263..1fd6bb0e 100644 --- a/ops/STATE.md +++ b/ops/STATE.md @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ it is authoritative when history is unavailable. **Keep it current. A stale STATE.md is worse than none:** it does not merely fail to help, it actively misleads an assessor that cannot check it. -Last updated: 2026-08-30 02:55 UTC, by Khaliq's session, on `main`. HANDOFF STATE — read the next section first. +Last updated: 2026-09-01 10:16 UTC, by the Relayflow Lead (flows-lead-1 on sf-mini), on `main`. **STATE.md gate-2 block rewritten; verdict unchanged (still AMBER).** A new evidence file — `ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md` — is cited from the gate-2 block; AMBER→GREEN is Khaliq's read on the enclosed evidence. ## Where the program is @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ Last updated: 2026-08-30 02:55 UTC, by Khaliq's session, on `main`. HANDOFF STAT fix restored -> ok. 19 passed; 0 failed repeated -> passed 20 / failed 0 out of 20 Gate 1 no longer carries a fix-on-trust. -- **Gates 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9: RED.** Not started. +- **Gates 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9: RED / AMBER as noted.** Gate 2 is AMBER (see block below); the rest are RED / not started. - **Gate 6 — integrations via relayfile: RED, and BLOCKED on gates 2-4.** Khaliq decided this on 2026-08-28 (option B), after the Lead escalated a real spec-vs-reality gap: RFC-0001 defines gate 6 as "every integration step in @@ -36,35 +36,49 @@ Last updated: 2026-08-30 02:55 UTC, by Khaliq's session, on `main`. HANDOFF STAT now — the design partner needs it and it does not depend on old-engine flows. But gate 6 is NOT green until real flows run on it (RFC-0001 §2 rule 2: "a gate is green only when the real workload runs on it"). -- **Gate 2 — proactive agent: AMBER, in progress, and it is the frontier.** - First code landed via **PR #14** (`e0f52e1`, merged 2026-08-28 22:01 UTC): - `kernel/relayflowd/src/engine/wake.rs` (event matching, dedupe claim, journal - entries), `relayflowd-core/src/event.rs` (Event, pattern matching, dedupe key - templating), `TriggerSpec` fields, a subscription registry keyed by - (flow, subscription, key) with claim repair, and the SDK's `event.submit` - verb plus trigger fields. - **Both pieces I previously listed as missing are in fact DONE**, and PR #14 - carried them. Verified on `main` at 23:40 UTC, literally: - `sh ops/cargo.sh test -p relayflowd --test event_wake` -> - `matching_event_wakes_once_with_fresh_context ... ok` (1 passed). The - wake-time context assembly is in `engine/wake.rs`; the idempotency proof is - `kernel/relayflowd/tests/event_wake.rs`. - **What remains is the RFC's own bar, which is higher than the primitives.** - RFC-0001 §3 gate 2 is done when a real proactive workload (`hn-monitor` or - `linear`) runs as a relayflow — not when the kernel can wake on an event. - Rule 2 governs: a gate is green only when the real workload runs on it. - - **PR #15 (`079f7c4`) took the first step and no more.** It added - `testdata/hn-monitor.flow.yaml`, its canonical spec, and - `kernel/relayflowd/tests/hn_monitor_integration.rs`. Verified by hand: - `flows check` -> `CHECK PASSED`, and the integration test passes inside the - full workspace run (19+19+1+1+26+5 passed, 0 failed). - - **A real external event HAS now woken it** — see PR #19 above, verified - against live Hacker News with exactly-once holding across repeated polls. - Gate 2 stays AMBER only pending Khaliq's read on whether a manually-invoked - poller satisfies "runs as a relayflow" under rule 2, or whether it must be - scheduled and unattended first. That is a judgement, not a missing part. +- **Gate 2 — proactive agent: AMBER, unattended trigger-plane proven, two clauses remain.** + The primitives are all landed: + - PR #14 (`e0f52e1`) — kernel wake, event matching, dedupe claim, `event.submit`. + - PR #15 (`079f7c4`) — `testdata/hn-monitor.flow.yaml` + integration test. + - PR #19 — live-HN → wake, exactly-once. + - PR #95 — `dir-watcher` poller (2nd workload primitive, non-provider). + - PR #120 (`201542a`, merged 2026-09-01 08:29 UTC) — + **`flows hn-monitor start`**, the CLI runner that turns the poller + into an unattended process. + + **New evidence:** `ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md` records a + live, unattended run of `flows hn-monitor start` against a local + `relayflowd serve`, driven by real Hacker News top-stories. Real story + IDs matched, deduped, dispatched under lease, and closed out with typed + `completionReason` — the full trigger → subscription → dispatch → + typed-failure loop journalled end to end. Counts, timings, ULIDs, and + one run's full journal are literal in that file — cite it directly + rather than restating specific numbers here (STATE.md counts drift, an + evidence transcript does not). + + **Why AMBER, not GREEN.** RFC-0001 §3 gate 2 has two clauses this + evidence does NOT close: + 1. **Trigger plane liveness-checked** (RFC-0001 §3 gate 2, the paragraph + ending "Native's silent-death problem"). RelayCron's deterministic-id + single-winner claim + `stale_after` sweep is the pattern. Not + implemented inside `relayflowd`. The poller runs; the kernel does not + yet notice if it stops. The same section calls this "a requirement, + not an option" — it is a stated done-when clause, not follow-up + hardening. + 2. **The analyze-agent step actually executing.** In the recorded run, + every step ended in `worker_error` because `hn-monitor start`'s + AgentWorker has no user-supplied step handler. The dispatch loop + works; the analyzer does not. Whether this reads as gate-2 scope + ("runs succeed") or gate-4 scope ("chief-as-relayflow supplies + the runtime") is Khaliq's call. + + **AMBER → GREEN is Khaliq's read** on the enclosed evidence, per this + block's prior wording ("that is a judgement, not a missing part") and + per the charter's standing rule that the Lead never merges / never + flips gates (`ops/AUTONOMY.md` and the "no self-merge" rail; RFC-0001 + covenant 3 governs declared human-in-the-loop *gates within a flow*, + which is a different thing). This session prepared evidence and left + the flip pending. ## HANDOFF (2026-08-30 03:05 UTC) — a lead is LIVE on sf-mini diff --git a/ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md b/ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a76d2421 --- /dev/null +++ b/ops/reviews/20260901-1050-gate2-live-run.md @@ -0,0 +1,243 @@ +# Gate-2 live-run evidence — 2026-09-01 08:37Z–10:16Z + +Captured by the Relayflow Lead (`flows-lead-1` on sf-mini) after PR #120 +(`flows hn-monitor start`) merged into main at 08:29Z. This file is an +evidence transcript. Whether it is enough to move gate 2 from AMBER to GREEN +is `ops/STATE.md`'s decision — the AMBER block there cites this file. + +**About the times in this file.** Every time is UTC, ending in `Z`. The +evidence window runs 2026-09-01 08:37Z (launch) → 10:16Z (observation +below), a ~1h39m span. In local Europe/Oslo wall-clock (CEST, UTC+2 on +this date) that is 10:37 → 12:16. `at_ms` values in the journal excerpts +below (Unix ms since epoch) resolve to times in that UTC window. All +sqlite / `ps` / `date` outputs pasted in the observation section are +from a single burst captured at 10:16:24Z, so they are internally +consistent. + +**About paths.** The primary observation was on `/tmp/gate2-live` on sf-mini +and will not survive a reboot. All artifacts are inlined below — the +sqlite outputs, the poller log, and one run's full journal are literal, +complete, and re-checkable from the contents of this file alone; the +`/tmp` paths appear only as citations of where the observation was made. + +## What this is proof of, and what it is not + +**Proof of:** the trigger + step-dispatch plane runs, unattended and +sustained, driven by a real external event stream (Hacker News +top-stories), with zero bespoke persistence and closed-set typed failure +kinds on the paths it exercises. This is *sustained execution* under real +events; it is not *crash / restart durability* — that is a separate +property this run did not exercise. + +**Not proof of:** +- The trigger plane surviving its own poller stopping — the + liveness-checked done-when clause in RFC-0001 §3 gate 2 (the paragraph + ending "Native's silent-death problem") is not implemented in + `relayflowd`. +- The analyze-story agent step executing successfully — every run ended + in `worker_error → step_failed` because `hn-monitor start`'s + AgentWorker has no user-supplied step handler. + +Both are itemized as outstanding follow-ups below. + +## Literal build outputs + + $ cd kernel && cargo build --release -p relayflowd + Compiling wait-timeout v0.2.1 + Compiling jsonschema v0.33.0 + Compiling relayflowd-core v0.1.0 (/Users/khaliqgant/AgentWorkforce/flows-cli/kernel/relayflowd-core) + Compiling clap v4.6.6 + Compiling rusqlite v0.37.0 + Compiling relayflowd-journal v0.1.0 (/Users/khaliqgant/AgentWorkforce/flows-cli/kernel/relayflowd-journal) + Compiling relayflowd v0.1.0 (/Users/khaliqgant/AgentWorkforce/flows-cli/kernel/relayflowd) + Finished `release` profile [optimized] target(s) in 3m 02s + + $ cd sdk && npm run build + + > @relayflows/sdk@0.1.0 build + > tsc && node scripts/make-cli-executable.mjs + +Both exited 0. + +## Literal launch commands + + $ mkdir /tmp/gate2-live + $ nohup kernel/target/release/relayflowd \ + --data-dir /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd serve \ + > /tmp/gate2-live/relayflowd.log 2>&1 & + $ nohup node sdk/dist/cli.js hn-monitor start \ + --data-dir /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd \ + --poll-interval-ms 30000 \ + testdata/hn-monitor.spec.canonical.json \ + > /tmp/gate2-live/hn-monitor.log 2>&1 & + +## Literal observation at 2026-09-01T10:16:24Z + + $ date -u '+%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ' + 2026-09-01T10:16:24Z + + $ cat /tmp/gate2-live/hn-monitor.log + hn-monitor: attached worker at /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/relayflowd.sock, poll every 30000ms + + $ cat /tmp/gate2-live/relayflowd.log + (empty file — relayflowd emits its journal to sqlite, not stdout) + + $ sqlite3 /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/relayflowd.sqlite3 "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM runs;" + 9 + + $ sqlite3 /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/relayflowd.sqlite3 "SELECT status, COUNT(*) FROM runs GROUP BY status;" + failed|9 + + $ sqlite3 /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/relayflowd.sqlite3 "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM event_dedupe;" + 9 + + $ sqlite3 /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/relayflowd.sqlite3 "SELECT dedupe_key FROM event_dedupe ORDER BY dedupe_key;" + hn.story_posted:49441609 + hn.story_posted:49493468 + hn.story_posted:49510514 + hn.story_posted:49511856 + hn.story_posted:49516059 + hn.story_posted:49517448 + hn.story_posted:49517584 + hn.story_posted:49517624 + hn.story_posted:49519939 + + $ ps -o pid,etime -p 59519,59585 + PID ELAPSED + 59519 01:38:45 + 59585 01:38:16 + +9 rows in `runs`, 9 rows in `event_dedupe`, 1 row per unique HN story ID — +kernel-side exactly-once observed at the subscription-claim boundary. Every +run in `failed` state; failure kind detail is in the next section. + +## All-runs terminal-entry survey + +To prove the rule table's "8 [now 9] subscription.matched" and "every run +ended in a declared completionReason" claims from the same instant (not by +extrapolating from one full-journal excerpt), this command reads +`subscription.matched` (seq 4) and `run.completed` (seq 7) from every +per-run sqlite in the runs/ directory: + + $ for f in /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/runs/*.sqlite3; do + sqlite3 "$f" \ + "SELECT '$(basename $f .sqlite3)|' || seq || '|' || entry_type + || '|' || substr(payload, 1, 90) + FROM entries + WHERE entry_type IN ('subscription.matched', 'run.completed') + ORDER BY seq;" + done + + 01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49517584","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E1WQT1QQ4W8PPGSR1AYXW5|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49517448","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E1WQT1QQ4W8PPGSR1AYXW5|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E1WQTPGYS9GRK741V849XP|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49516059","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E1WQTPGYS9GRK741V849XP|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E1WQVBKYZHG0HFHKKG4SFE|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49517624","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E1WQVBKYZHG0HFHKKG4SFE|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E1WQVZ20EZTX7GWP0FX1N8|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49511856","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E1WQVZ20EZTX7GWP0FX1N8|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E3D5PWRHE9EKFH81FMF2WW|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49510514","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E3D5PWRHE9EKFH81FMF2WW|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E4J7C9DE5R62ATZJM39TPK|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49493468","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E4J7C9DE5R62ATZJM39TPK|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E6PT4FS203Z1K8Y5K6Q4GS|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49441609","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E6PT4FS203Z1K8Y5K6Q4GS|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + 01M1E7B62NYZ84HS9YPY5V0PM8|4|subscription.matched|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49519939","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context" + 01M1E7B62NYZ84HS9YPY5V0PM8|7|run.completed|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_fail + +Nine rows × two entries = 18 lines above. Every run has a +`subscription.matched` at seq 4 with an HN story ID matching one of the +nine `event_dedupe` rows, and a `run.completed` at seq 7 whose payload +starts with `"completionReason":"step_fail` (truncated by `substr(..., 90)` +— full form is `step_failed`, seen unabridged in the full journal below). + +## Full journal of one run (all 7 entries, verbatim) + +Run `01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3` (oldest). Full command and result: + + $ sqlite3 /tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/runs/01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3.sqlite3 \ + "SELECT seq, entry_type, step_id, at_ms, payload FROM entries ORDER BY seq;" + + 1|run.spawned||1788251889453|{"created_by":"protocol-v0","journal_version":1,"parent_run_id":null,"spec":{"description":"Analyze newly posted Hacker News stories for agent and automation relevance.","name":"hn-monitor","steps":[{"depends_on":[],"id":"analyze-story","instruction":"Analyze the triggering HN story from the wake context and determine if it is relevant to AI agents/automation. Output a JSON summary with: story title, relevance score (1-10), and reasoning.","max_iterations":1,"recovery_mode":"reset","retry":{"initial_backoff_ms":100,"jitter_percent":20,"max_backoff_ms":60000,"multiplier":2},"type":"agent","verification":{"json_schema":{"properties":{"reasoning":{"type":"string"},"relevance_score":{"maximum":10,"minimum":1,"type":"integer"},"story_title":{"type":"string"}},"required":["story_title","relevance_score","reasoning"],"type":"object"}}}],"triggers":[{"dedupe_key_template":"{{event.type}}:{{payload.id}}","event_type":"hn.story_posted","executor":"agent-worker","id":"hn-story-posted","pattern":{"type":"story"}}],"version":"0.1.0"},"spec_hash":"7694278172bdf670308d8820631e6ce8eecd4dd83ba26cb7987012c9c4fcd2ca"} + 2|subscription.registered||1788251889453|{"event_type":"hn.story_posted","executor":"agent-worker","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted"} + 3|event.received||1788251889453|{"event":{"payload":{"id":49517584,"type":"story"},"type":"hn.story_posted"},"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49517584","matched_subscription_id":"hn-story-posted"} + 4|subscription.matched||1788251889453|{"event_key":"hn.story_posted:49517584","subscription_id":"hn-story-posted","wake_context":{"epoch_summary":{"open_steps":["analyze-story"]},"triggering_event":{"payload":{"id":49517584,"type":"story"},"type":"hn.story_posted"}}} + 5|step.attempt.started|analyze-story|1788251889462|{"executor":"hn-monitor-59585","idempotency_key":"f6d69110a48ef254071ecd2d38f1761730e39cb5347b42a047ac963542d32ea4","lease_deadline_ms":1788251919462,"lease_id":"01M1E1WQSPYKPR1C3K1P8QAAN7","max_iterations":1,"pins":{"streams":[],"workspace":[]},"recovery_mode":"reset","step_type":"agent"} + 6|step.completed|analyze-story|1788251889468|{"budget":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completed_by":"hn-monitor-59585","completionReason":"worker_error","disposition":"step_done","effects":[],"end_pins":{"streams":[],"workspace":[]},"next_attempt_at_ms":null,"output":null,"verification":null} + 7|run.completed||1788251889469|{"budget_total":{"dollars":"0","tokens_in":0,"tokens_out":0},"completionReason":"step_failed","failed_step_id":"analyze-story"} + +`at_ms=1788251889453` decodes to `2026-09-01T08:38:09.453Z`, which is inside +the observation window at the top of this file. The run journalled seven +entries with typed `entry_type` values (`run.spawned`, +`subscription.registered`, `event.received`, `subscription.matched`, +`step.attempt.started`, `step.completed`, `run.completed`) — no raw stack +trace anywhere, closed-set failure kinds at seq 6 (`worker_error`) and +seq 7 (`step_failed`). + +Seq 6 pairs `disposition:"step_done"` with `completionReason:"worker_error"` +— the two fields describe different things and this pairing is intentional. +`disposition` names *how* the step surface closed (the journal boundary is +sealed, the worker released the lease, no orphan effects); `completionReason` +names *why* the step's payload could not be produced (the worker had no +handler to execute the `agent` step-type). A future reader changing either +should know they are orthogonal. + +## Rule-by-rule status (RFC-0001 §3 gate 2 + §2 rule 2) + +| Rule | Status | Evidence source (in this file) | +|---|---|---| +| Real event → real run | ✅ | 9 `subscription.matched` rows across 9 per-run journals — see the all-runs survey above; one full journal excerpt below shows payload `{"id":49517584,"type":"story"}` reaching the wake context | +| Zero bespoke persistence functions | ✅ | `sdk/src/cli/hn-monitor.ts` and `sdk/src/hn-poller.ts` in the merged PR #120 have no state stores — every fact above lives in `relayflowd.sqlite3` and per-run `runs/.sqlite3` | +| Retried at step granularity | PARTIAL | seq 5 shows dispatch under a `lease_id` and `idempotency_key`; no actual retry fires because `worker_error` is a terminal disposition — retry SHAPE is wired, retry of REAL WORK not observed | +| Deduped by idempotency key | ✅ | `event_dedupe` has 9 rows, one per unique HN story ID | +| Fail-closed typed failures (covenant 2) | PARTIAL | 9 of 9 runs ended in a declared `completionReason` (all `step_failed` at seq 7, driven by `worker_error` at seq 6) — see the all-runs survey above for the literal payloads. Real-agent-work failure kinds not yet exercised because the analyzer never ran | +| Unattended + scheduled (sustained) | ✅ | at 10:16:24Z, `ps -o etime` on the two PIDs shows ~1h39m uptime (kernel 01:38:45, poller 01:38:16 — inlined above); poller log holds one line, the attach message. Crash / restart durability is NOT proven by this run — see the top-of-file scoping note | +| Trigger plane liveness-checked | ❌ | not implemented in `relayflowd`; see follow-up A | +| Analyze-agent step executes successfully | ❌ | see follow-up B | + +## Outstanding follow-ups against RFC-0001 gate 2 + +**A. Trigger-plane liveness sweep.** RFC-0001 §3 gate 2's done-when +paragraph includes "The trigger plane is *liveness-checked*" and the same +section's Native lesson calls this "a requirement, not an option." Pattern +is RelayCron-style: a deterministic-id single-winner claim plus a +`stale_after` reconciliation. Not implemented inside `relayflowd`. This is +a stated done-when clause, not a hardening follow-up. + +**B. Analyze-agent step successful execution.** Every run recorded here +terminated in `worker_error → step_failed` because `hn-monitor start`'s +AgentWorker has no user-supplied step handler — the CLI is the poller + +attach seam, not the analyzer. Wiring an actual agent runtime (a Claude / +codex / local-LLM shim) that satisfies the `analyze-story` step and produces +verified JSON matching its schema is the remaining piece. Whether this +reads as gate-2 scope ("runs succeed") or gate-4 scope ("chief-as-relayflow +supplies the runtime") is Khaliq's read. + +## Appendix — session identifiers + +Not needed to re-check the evidence above; recorded for provenance only. + +- Host: sf-mini (Europe/Oslo, CEST = UTC+2 on 2026-09-01) +- relayflowd PID: 59519 +- hn-monitor PID: 59585 +- relayflowd `--data-dir`: `/tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd` +- One-run sqlite path used above: `/tmp/gate2-live/.relayflowd/runs/01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3.sqlite3` +- Ulids of the 9 runs recorded at 10:16:24Z: + 01M1E1WQS62ENMTAFWR2PTYQZ3 + 01M1E1WQT1QQ4W8PPGSR1AYXW5 + 01M1E1WQTPGYS9GRK741V849XP + 01M1E1WQVBKYZHG0HFHKKG4SFE + 01M1E1WQVZ20EZTX7GWP0FX1N8 + 01M1E3D5PWRHE9EKFH81FMF2WW + 01M1E4J7C9DE5R62ATZJM39TPK + 01M1E6PT4FS203Z1K8Y5K6Q4GS + 01M1E7B62NYZ84HS9YPY5V0PM8 + +## Author + +Relayflow Lead session (`flows-lead-1` on sf-mini), 2026-09-01. This file is +evidence; the AMBER→GREEN judgment call is reserved for Khaliq per the +gate-2 block's history (prior STATE.md wording: "that is a judgement, not a +missing part").